Ladder logic uses ladder diagrams to express logic operations for PLC programming. Relay logic is used to create electrical circuits for specific functions.
Ladder logic is a programming language primarily used to create and represent programs through ladder diagrams, which are based on circuit diagrams. The main application of ladder logic is developing programmable logic controllers (PLC) software for industrial use. Electrical Cut Off Switch
Ladder logic started as a method to document the design and build of relay racks in process control and manufacturing applications. Here, each relay rack was represented by a ladder diagram symbol. The symbol was connected to devices below them, which can be described as visually similar to vertical rails. The relay symbols appeared to be visually similar to ladder rungs.
Ladder logic is a rule-based language, not an imperative or procedural one. Each “ladder rung” represents a rule, which, when implemented to relays and electromechanical devices, is executed immediately and simultaneously.
However, applying the program to a PLC allows the rules to be executed sequentially via software in a continuous loop. If the loop is executed swiftly enough, the effect is perceived as akin to simultaneous and immediate execution within the time tolerance required.
The potential of the PLC in use must be considered when using ladder logic programming. Not all electromechanical devices are capable of processing complex programs. If not done correctly, rules may remain partially unprocessed as the device fails to keep up.
Ladder logic is reliable when it comes to programming simple yet critical systems and revamping legacy hardwired systems to create more modern programmable ones. The programming language is also popular for complex automation systems, such as in the automobile and electronic industries. Industrial PLCs that leverage ladder logic in their programming are useful for sequential control of manufacturing operations and processes.
A key benefit of ladder logic is its usability, even among personnel without a programming background. Using conventional engineering symbols that industrial teams are generally familiar with allows for quicker programming.
However, this advantage is occasionally absent in ladder logic systems with proprietary programs. This is because manufacturers may not always use the same symbols and standards as other manufacturers or even the same symbols in different products or models. Sometimes, this means programs may not be ported easily to another PLC model and may even have to be rewritten entirely.
See More: What Is Telematics? Meaning, Working, Types, Benefits, and Applications in 2022
Unlike software-based ladder logic, relay logic is a hardwired control system that leverages instrumentation, timers, switches, contactors, relays, actuators, and motors. Traditionally, the primary application of relay logic has been automating industrial machines and processes. This has typically been achieved with heavy hardware, including electronic devices and wiring.
At one time, relay logic was a cutting-edge development for industrial automation. Today, it is generally considered a legacy system, and its implementation is associated with challenges such as high switchboard space use, labor-intensive installation, and tricky troubleshooting. Any modifications to control functions are also complex and tedious due to the hardware-centric nature of relay logic.
As microprocessors became more popular, programmers realized that the functionality of relay logic controls could be digitalized. And so began the task of programming relay logic controls and storing them in computers. By the late 1960s, programmable logic controllers (PLC) became a reality.
In a PLC, relay logic is used to formulate logical expressions and automate industrial processes and machinery. The programming language used to create relay logic in a PLC is known as ladder logic. This breakthrough in industrial automation is why relay logic is close to complete redundancy.
See More: What Is GPS (Global Positioning System)? Meaning, Types, Working, Examples, and Applications
Ladder logic is a graphical programming language used for programmable logic controllers (PLC), where logic operations are expressed with symbolic notation using ladder diagrams.
Relay logic is a simple method to create electrical circuits for specific functions, including counting, timing, switching, and logic operations, using electromechanical relays.
Ladder Logic vs. Relay Logic
Source: Instrumentation Tools Opens a new window
Let us learn more about the key differences between ladder logic and relay logic.
Visually speaking, ladder logic appears similar to a ladder. The same electrical ladder diagrams generally used in relay logic serve as the basis of the structure of ladder logic programming. Traditionally, such diagrams would document connections between devices on relay panels. Two vertical rails represent the power supply, with the positive power rail on the left flowing to the negative power rail to the right using the physical devices connected to the rungs. Meanwhile, the horizontal “ladder rungs” contain the control elements, also known as “coils” and “contacts.” These elements emulate the properties of physical switches and relays. While contacts act as sensors or input conditions, coils represent the actuators or output devices. Each element is either in the open or closed state, and the state of an element determines the path to be followed by the control logic. Logic flows are read from left to right.
In the programming process, contacts and coils are arranged in a sequence that correlates with the desired order of operations. Once an input condition is fulfilled and a contact is “closed,” the logic flow is allowed to move on to the next rung and an output action is allowed to be triggered via a coil being energized. Thus, the behavior of activated switches and relays is emulated based on specific conditions.
Before any programmed logic is executed, the CPU analyzes the physical inputs and outputs linked with the input and output modules and updates their status in the memory table.
Once all inputs and outputs are assessed, the CPU executes each specific rung or sub-rung, starting from the left to the right. Once the CPU processes the last rung, the real-world outputs are updated, and the program is looped to run everything again. This execution process will stay live until the CPU receives power and is set to RUN mode.
Ladder logic programming is well-suited for applications that call for sequential or discrete control, such as process control, machinery automation, and manufacturing lines. The graphical representation feature simplifies modification and troubleshooting because engineers can easily visualize the logic flow and make the necessary adjustments. Ladder logic may be visually simple; however, it can handle intricate control sequences and is, therefore, a versatile tool for industrial automation.
The switch and circuit are in the “open” state in the NO contact position. Therefore, the current flow within the circuit is disabled. Conversely, a closed switch completes the circuit in the NC contact position. Here, closing the primary circuit or coil causes the current to flow through the coil linked with that circuit. This creates a magnetic field, energizing the relay and closing the contacts, enabling the current flow within the circuit.
For the state of the contact to change from NO to NC or vice versa, a small electrical signal must be applied. Simply put, a small amount of current through the relay changes the contact state.
In LD, control logic is represented through electrical circuit diagrams. These diagrams chiefly include rungs, rails, and symbols to represent different control elements and devices linked using lines.
LD electronically visualizes a representation of control logic to increase accessibility for engineers and other technical personnel. By emulating the relay control circuit format electronically, ladder diagrams simplify the design and understanding of control systems.
Relay logic systems consist of electrical contacts, relays, and coils physically linked to building control circuits. These circuits replicate electromechanical relay operations, traditionally used in control applications before the digital technology era.
In contrast to the robust representation schema used in ladder logic, relay logic is far more reliant on physical connections and components. This makes it more challenging to design, troubleshoot, or change.
Ladder logic flexibility gives technical teams a key advantage, especially in fast-paced industrial environments that commonly require swift adjustments to control processes.
Unlike ladder logic, relay logic cannot be leveraged for dynamic systems with frequent changes.
The software-powered programmability of ladder logic streamlines the creation, modification, and documentation of control programs.
Here, “programming” is labor-intensive and requires wiring and hardware setup precision. This is time-consuming and calls for an in-depth understanding of electrical connections. Hard-to-spot errors can crop up if relay logic “programming” is not carried out accurately.
The ability of ladder logic to handle complexity without requiring the deployment of extensive hardware gives it an advantage over relay logic in terms of maintenance ease and cost-effectiveness.
Relay logic suffers compared to ladder logic because the setup may greatly increase in cost and complexity as control systems become more convoluted.
The savings in cost and space offered by ladder logic are especially useful in industrial environments with limited space and a high emphasis on cost-effectiveness.
Naturally, the costs associated with purchasing and maintaining such a setup would be higher in the long run.
The simple troubleshooting and maintenance enabled by ladder logic help industrial teams significantly decrease downtime and operational disruptions.
Additionally, because relay logic is hardware-centric, systems can experience longer downtimes under maintenance.
Leveraging ladder logic for modernization ensures up-to-date control systems and seamless integration with emerging technologies, thus offering greater investment value.
This schema does not feature the integration capabilities of ladder logic. If a need for modernization arises, a complete overhaul of the control system might be required.
As safety is crucial in industrial environments, the simplicity with which ladder logic enables incorporating safety features is a key advantage.
However, the complexities associated with the manual nature of relay logic often make it more difficult to set and maintain safety protocols in line with modern-day industrial standards.
With digitized documentation enabled by ladder logic, the management of control systems is simplified, and tracking changes and ensuring consistency becomes easier.
This is generally considered a less efficient alternative, especially when system modifications need to be made.
The language is crucial for programming critical functions in modern industrial setups and for revamping traditional hardwired systems to transform them into digital programs.
Ladder logic programming is leveraged in both simple industrial setups and sophisticated automation systems, including plants that manufacture automobiles and electronic devices.
A key reason for this is its intuitive nature, which allows the language to be used for high-utility graphical representations of circuit designs of any scale. This intuitive nature of the programming language makes it easy for professionals to understand it.
Further, ladder logic uses familiar engineering symbols. Even engineers and technicians without an in-depth understanding of programming can program and implement ladder logic in industrial environments. For instance, industrial operators without prior software training experience could use ladder logic programming for debugging or maintaining industrial applications.
Utility-wise, ladder logic programming gives operators a real-time graphical representation of power flow. This allows for the easy troubleshooting of power faults. Plus, circuits created with ladder logic feature greater ease of use and reliability than complex electrical components. This can potentially lead to improved lifespan and usability of connected equipment.
Finally, automated control systems that leverage PLCs over relays have distinct advantages, including the easy development of complex logical expressions; simple and cost-effective modification or expansion of control systems as required; decreased costs associated with installation, components, and design; virtually zero maintenance; seamless monitoring and reporting; and simplified process optimization and debugging.
Characterized by a heavy reliance on hardwired connections and electromechanical relays, relay logic programming offers advantages and challenges in modern industry.
Reliability is one of the key benefits of relay logic. Over the past few decades, electromechanical relays have consistently delivered dependable output in difficult industrial setups. Robustness, strength, and the ability to work in tough conditions are benefits that relay logic setups share with ladder logic setups. In simple, critical applications with a near-zero tolerance for failure, relay logic can still serve as a trustworthy choice.
Further, relay logic is straightforward to understand, implement, and manage. It is highly hardware-based, making it a simple choice for applications that do not need complex control algorithms. Engineers and technicians can understand relay logic operations quickly.
In certain scenarios, relay logic may even prove to be more cost-effective than ladder logic. This can be because the components used in relay logic systems are more affordable, maintenance is more straightforward, and the human resources required to operate it generally do not need advanced knowledge or tools.
Finally, the manual nature of relay logic can be a double-edged sword in maintenance. On the one hand, this feature makes the language less suitable for complicated control tasks. On the other hand, it greatly simplifies certain aspects of maintenance. For instance, technicians with a lower skill barrier can physically inspect, test, troubleshoot, and fix connections and relays.
See More: What Is the Internet of Everything? Meaning, Examples, and Uses
Ladder logic and relay logic are both important forms of programming logic in the industrial space. However, they represent distinct approaches to industrial control. While relay logic has historical significance that helped shape industrial control as we know it today, ladder logic has built upon it to emerge as a cutting-edge standard for designing, implementing, and maintaining industrial control logic.
The graphical, software-based ladder logic features greater flexibility and compatibility with modern automation solutions, which makes it the more obvious choice for industrial use. However, relay logic remains unique in specific industrial applications where its reliability and simplicity are leveraged.
Understanding the key differences between ladder logic and relay logic is important to select the most appropriate approach for industrial automation.
Keyboard Foot Switch Did this article provide a comprehensive understanding of ladder logic vs. relay logic? Share your thoughts with us on Facebook Opens a new window , X Opens a new window , or LinkedIn Opens a new window !